Watch Out for This Income-Killing Online Writing Scam

Carol Tice

Businessman taking the baitIt’s an exciting time, when you finally start to get some traction as a freelance writer.

You land a client or two, and start writing. Maybe you score a gig with a popular blog, or you’re writing for a big website.

Having highly visible bylines often leads to emails from prospective clients. They’re impressed by who you’re writing for, and they’d like to hire you.

Unfortunately, what they’d like to hire you to write is not always legit.

I’ve gotten shady requests many times because of the visibility of my Forbes blog, and I know I’m far from alone.

For instance, here’s a discussion thread we recently had in Freelance Writers Den:

 

The shady request

One member got this prospect nibble:

A marketing consultant contacted me, who represents a client looking to build relationships with writers who regularly contribute to blogs and online publications in their field. I’m sort of confused about what I’m being asked to do. Here’s some of our interaction:

I asked: “You’re looking for writers to publish articles on third party blogs and online publications that mention your client’s products? We’d brainstorm an article idea, I’d write it and then pitch it to appropriate sites for publishing? How does the pay work? Do I only get paid if it gets published?”

They answered: “Yes, that’s essentially the gist. This seems to work well with writers that contribute regularly to specific publications, because they’re able to use relationships that are already established instead of pitching new blogs. So for example, if you came up with an article that fit any of the pubs you currently write for and [the topic] supported a relevant client mention, then you wouldn’t have to worry about pitching new sites.”

Does this sound ethical? Is it okay to get paid by a publication and also by a corporation that was mentioned in the piece?

Is she just asking for me to use her client as a source, when appropriate? And is it wrong to accept pay for that? This whole thing sounds a little weird to me.–Tamara

Ignoring the rules

Not every business owner knows the rules of journalism: that the reporter needs to be impartial in what they write, and can’t ever profit from what they are saying is ‘news’ or a good resource in a story.

Still other businesses *do* know the rules. But they prefer not to play by them.

What this client is asking is flat-out unethical, if you haven’t guessed.

They’re asking to brazenly use you, and your existing client relationships, to market their business, on the sly. That it puts your reputation in danger? Well, clearly they don’t care.

If you’re a paid writer for a blog or website, links you include should only be useful resources you decided, independently, are valuable and relevant to the story. Getting paid to pop in links to companies that want visibility on one of your client’s sites…that’s a Bozo no-no.

The perils of double dipping

When you’re being paid both by your client, and by the sources you include in your posts or articles, it’s known in journalism circles as double-dipping. You can’t get paid on both ends.

Basically, these sleazy companies are both cheap and lazy. Instead of hiring a PR firm and pitching their company as a source to reporters and hoping they will take an interest — which is what they’re supposed to do — they’d like to cut to the chase and simply buy your interest.

The problem has become so widespread online that many big outlets are making writers sign a contract attesting that they are not including paid links. At Forbes, they make us re-sign a pledge not to do it every single quarter.

Let me quote from the policy update I just got from them:

Link Schemes

When you link somewhere for perceived search or monetary benefits rather than usefulness or credit, then you are participating in a link scheme. Link schemes are against Forbes and Google guidelines. They are very simple for Google to detect, and they will adversely affect your website as well as forbes.com’s ranking in Google. Examples include:

  • Buying or selling links that pass PageRank. This includes exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links; exchanging goods or services for links; or sending someone a “free” product in exchange for them writing about it and including a link
  • Article marketing or guest posting containing links with optimized anchor text in articles – anchor text example: “There are many wedding rings on the market.”
  • Advertorials or native advertising where payment is received for articles that include links that pass PageRank
  • More info at: https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66356

Forbes has zero tolerance for link schemes. Should we or Google discover you are engaging in this practice, your publishing rights on forbes.com will immediately be terminated.”

If your client discovers you’re double dipping, you’re likely going to be done writing for them. I know Forbes has let writers go over this, and I’m sure they’re not the only site on active patrol against paid-for mentions and links, either.

Why are big websites on the warpath about this? Because if it became known that their useful posts were in fact full of paid links, their reputation as a news source would be ruined, too.

It’ll be hard to get editors interested in your query letter if word is on the street that you’re for sale to the highest bidder, as far as the content of your posts.

Compromise on the cheap

When the writer above asked for more details on how much pay this prospect was willing to put up to get their link slipped into posts on big sites, this was the response:

“My client is looking for editorial placements in articles that willingly came from the authors of those articles. While we are willing to pay for the collaborative time and effort, we’re not looking for sponsored content, advertorials, or paid disclosures.

My client is looking to team up with trusted authors to make them aware of some great free resources they offer and see if those resources might be a good fit for any upcoming content the author plans to write. These articles/posts would not be promotional in nature or only focused on the client. We’re just looking for a link in the form of a helpful reference within the article.”

And there you have it. They don’t want to pay for a sponsored post or article — which might run them $500-$1,200, and would make clear they bought the mention.

No, they’re looking to ruin your career and get you fired on the cheap. They’d like to slip you $50 or $100 for a link and call it good. (I’ve gotten similar offers to accept paid posts on this blog from link-seekers, at similar rates. No, thanks.)

You’ve got to love the way this prospect spun what they’re doing, too. Especially how they make clear that if you were to disclose that they paid you for the link — which is what you should ethically do — then they’re not interested.

If you’re desperate for money, look at taking a part-time job while you build up your finances.

No matter how tempting it might seem to take that extra cash for slipping in a link, say no. If you’re thinking your client need never know…trust me, they will find out.

your shortcut to success banner ad for freelance writers

61 Comments

  1. Lisa V

    I was just approached by a blogger who wants to use a few of my posts for a book she’s putting together with other bloggers. I haven’t asked about compensation yet, but, assuming there will be some, does this sound legit? I’m new to blogging, and I’m not so sure I want her making money off of my material. Do you think it would be worth the exposure (I’m working on getting a novel published in the meantime), or should I say thanks, but no thanks? What questions do I need to ask?
    Thanks.

    • Carol Tice

      I’d need to know a lot more about the situation, Lisa — but it’s not usually about payment, but credibility and exposure, when you agree to have a post of yours in someone else’s collection.

      One thing you might ask about is, I did one ebook with 40 of my blog’s guest posts, and gave all those authors the chance to a) claim it in their Amazon author profile and b) affiliate sell it to earn 50% commissions through my site. So those are things you might ask about, where if you promote it, you would earn some.

  2. J Raju

    I happen to land on this post when I myself mailed Mrs Carol for her service and she guided me here. Thank you for this share.

    Being part of digital agency, I keep track of our client’s competitor. I have seen many client’s competitors link on top tier publication and wonder how they do it? Obviously they are paid post.

    I mean to say that Your post and links don’t hurt the publication reputation if content is relevant and link is placed naturally. In coming years, Paid Guest Posting will be in demand. That time, I wonder how many mails you be reading in a day that seeks your guest posting service.

    • Carol Tice

      I’m getting several requests to throw paid links into my posts every day, at this point, since you ask, J. I always refuse.

      If you paid me $1 million for your link, it wouldn’t be enough to compensate for the loss of my journalistic career that will come when magazines learn I’m for sale, and that my ethics have been compromised.

      Paid posts that say “Sponsored post” at the top are another matter, and are fine. And certainly, there’s plenty of legitimate demand for ghostwriters for sponsored posts — I wrote a package of articles at one point for a sponsored section UPS did in Entrepreneur, for instance. But paid posts have to be clearly marked and not passed off as reporting or editorial. Sometimes, brands get linked and mentioned — because the reporter thinks they’re a good resource. Independent of being paid to say so.

      I think companies such as yours like to delude themselves that the “links don’t hurt your reputation if the link is placed ‘naturally'” because they don’t care what happens to me as the writer or to that publication — they want to justify corrupting the newsgathering process because ultimately, they only care about getting ink for themselves.

      I can tell you that most online sites of major publications are now having journalists sign a sworn statement that they are NOT accepting paid links — and they are aggressively firing anyone they catch at it.

  3. Alicia Rades

    Great article, Carol! I particularly love that you point out that it would hurt the publication’s reputation, too. I think this is something I’ll add to my article on the topic (I actually have written about this several times). I really only talked about the writer’s relationship with the client and the publication, but it’s important to realize why publications are so against it as well.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. The Myth of Publicity: Why You Should Never Work For Free - […] at Make a Living Writing (a great resource and one that I happily link to!) has a great example…
  2. Navigating the Tricky World of Hired Guest Posting - […] Tice recently went so far as to call this kind of writing opportunity a scam. Freelance writers work hard…

Related Posts

You CAN Write a Query Letter That Gets a “Yes”: 5 Resources

Freelance writer getting a gig after learning to write a query letter.

Love them or hate them, queries are one of the most important marketing tools for any freelancer who wants to write for magazines. And the skills you learn from writing a good query letter also help business writers and copywriters pitch their potential clients.

If you’ve been sending queries off into space and never getting a reply, you may think it’s impossible to break into new magazines. But it’s not true! Editors are always looking for new talent.

To help you learn to write a query letter that will get you the gig, we’ve pulled together a collection of five of our best posts on pitching:

Can’t Write? Try These 9 Ideas for Writing Motivation

It’s the bane of every freelance writer’s life: You know you need to sit yourself down and get some writing done, but nothing happens. The writing motivation just isn’t there. Sometimes, you can't even make yourself sit down with the computer -- even if you...