7 Types of Articles That Editors Hate and Don’t Want to Pay You For

Carol Tice

Angry editor doesn't like your storyEver wonder why your query letter to a magazine didn’t get a response?

It could be because the type of story you pitched is one the magazine doesn’t accept — or does, but expects to get for free.

If you’re in this to get great-paying article assignments, you need to understand the types of articles that make editors cough up the big bucks.

This is particularly hard, I think, for writers who’ve been mostly posting on their own blogs, or writing for content mills. The parameters of what’s desirable there are radically different from what magazines want.

Here’s a look at seven types of articles that make editors want to turn down your idea:

1. I’m the expert

Often, budding writers who are former lawyers, accountants, insurance brokers, or some other type of professional have a history of contributing articles to their organization newsletter as a volunteer. When you show those clips and pitch more articles based on your expertise and pitch similar advice pieces, you may be disappointed to find publications expect them to be free.

To get paid to write articles, you have to position yourself as the writer, not the expert. You’ll be expected to go out and interview experts and report their points of view. This is a big shift, but one that will take you away from freebie articles to promote your profession and into the world of good-paying articles.

2. I have an agenda

Many of the story ideas I see when we review ideas in 4-Week Journalism School stem from something the writer wants to advocate for — say, that parents should encourage their children to journal.

If you have a topic about which you have formed a strong opinion, it will be hard to report an unbiased story in which you quote experts on both sides of an issue. You won’t talk to that expert who thinks lack of exercise is the biggest problem with our youth today and they should stow the notebook and go shoot some hoops.

Your story will end up lopsided and biased. If an editor even suspects you can’t be evenhanded with a story, they’re not going to give it a green light.

3. I have a HIDDEN agenda

Sometimes a writer has something they’re hot to promote — but they don’t disclose how they might personally benefit from promoting it.

For instance, I recently saw a travel-magazine pitch from a writer whose day job is with his country’s travel bureau, all about the advantages of coming to visit…his country! Pitching a story like this without disclosing who he works for is a conflict of interest. Obviously, this writer would have earned kudos from his boss and possibly even gotten a raise if he could stimulate more tourism business through this article, so the pitch was completely self-interested.

Trying to slip a piece like this by your editor is a great way to find yourself banned from writing for that publication ever again, once your deception comes to light. And trust me, it will.

4. I want to do an investigative expose´

You’ve discovered a thorny issue or wrongdoing that the public needs to know about and you’re all fired up to get that story told. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to get a piece like this assigned as a freelancer, especially if it’s your first pitch to a publication. You’ll have more luck with publications where you already have an established track record.

The reason is that investigative work tends to be very time-consuming and require a deep understanding of journalism ethics. When you make accusations, you have to be very sure of your facts, or your publication risks getting sued out of existence. An editor is unlikely to trust an untried writer to dive into something that is potentially legally actionable and could take months to report.

This is why most investigative work is done by staff writers, where the publication has enough staff to spare someone for a big block of time. I once did an investigative piece as a staffer that I researched on and off for nearly a year. At the end, we concluded that while I had found an intriguing case of small-time charity fraud and facts were well-reported, the story didn’t reveal enough useful information to our publication’s readers to be worth the large amount of editorial space required to tell the story. The piece never ran.

Trust me, as a freelance writer, you don’t want to go down this kind of sinkhole and end up not earning after a ton of work. Also, quite often the expose a writer wants to do has to do with an issue they’ve got a personal point of view and agenda on…so see #2 again on that problem.

5. My story makes your advertisers look bad

You’re in double-trouble if the perceived wrong you are on a mission to right is something that is committed by the advertisers of your target publication.

For instance, I recently heard from a writer who wanted to do an investigative piece and prove that the major drug companies are conspiring to keep the public from knowing about and using natural remedies. Her idea was to pitch this to a lifestyle magazine full of ads for aspirin, Viagra and other big-pharma products. In going over that scenario with me, she suddenly realized why this story idea was a non-starter.

Yes, there is a division between editorial and advertising at most reputable publications, and the ad department can’t tell the editors what to write…but the publication also does have to stay in business. You probably need to find another venue if you’d like to take potshots at the people who pay their bills.

6. I want to vent

Something happened in your life that made you frustrated or angry, and you’d like to tell the world about it. These make great first-person essays…and the problem is those rarely pay well. Most see the light of day as free letters to the editor.

The reason these don’t pay well is vent articles rarely provide practical, useful information to readers. Helpful info is at the heart of the vast majority of well-paid articles, so your vent tends to get a “pass” from the editor. The way to sell these is to angle it away from being a vent and turn it into a useful case study others can benefit from, as I did when my blog was declared a malicious website by Facebook. By pitching the useful-lessons angle, I was able to get an editor’s OK to make it part of my paid blog for Forbes.

7. I’ve noticed a news peg, but don’t have an angle

Often, magazines will tie a story in with an upcoming event — the running of the bulls in Pamplona, or the 20th anniversary of a prominent local business. These create a “news peg,” or timeliness element that’s good to have in an article pitch…the problem is, you won’t be the only writer who’s thought of it. So if you pitch, “I’d like to write about the anniversary of Martin Luther King’s ‘I have a dream’ speech,” you’re only halfway there.

What will you say that hasn’t been said before about this event or institution? Without something fresh, this is more like a pitch to write a school paper (“What MLK’s ‘I have a dream’ speech means to me”) than a magazine article.

Will you do a roundup on how many streets in your town are named after MLK? Interview a surviving colleague? Cover an event being held in honor of the day? Catch us up on where MLK’s children are now, because you have exclusive access to them for interviews?

A strong story angle combined with a news peg can work great to get you the sale, but the fact that an anniversary is happening won’t do it alone. Without a defined approach, these articles could also ramble all over and lack focus, so the editor tends to shy away.

What article ideas have you had trouble selling? Leave a comment and I’ll try to help you refine your idea.

P.S. Congrats to Amanda @SkilfulScribe, who won the free ticket to 4-Week J-School!



  1. Don Wallace

    Good points and a very handy list.

    I’m scratching my head just a tiny bit over the prohibition of point #2, though: “I have an agenda”. I have seen MANY (presumably) objective pieces out in the wild that have a very obvious and clear agenda (or, I would call it, point of view), but they are accepted as journalism anyway.

    Can you give examples of open (not hidden) agendas that will cause a piece to be rejected? The only clear “no go” I can think of is to submit a piece that clearly doesn’t reflect the policies of the publication. (Such as, say, an article advocating green energy subsidies, submitted to the National Review.)

    • Carol Tice

      When you close your pitch with “I personally journal with my kids and believe every family should do so…” the editor is going to run.

      When you read a piece and there’s only one side of the story, a journalistic failure has occurred. Not to say it doesn’t happen, but editors WILL try to avoid them, so if you signal in your pitch that your mind is made up about this topic, you’re going to turn them off.

    • Don Wallace

      Thanks for that example – that clarifies it.

      But an approach like the one you cite is extremely common in the blogging world.

      It seems that the common style of selecting blog article subjects – the first person op-ed piece – is not what gets published by paying publications.

    • Carol Tice

      Exactly — there’s a mental shift that has to happen, to a different sort of writing where it’s not all about your personal thoughts. A lot of writers who come out of blogging have trouble with it, but if you can do it, there’s a lot of opportunity to earn more.

  2. Genita Kovacevich-Costello

    I’ve put together a query on “Badges Women Wear” that I’ve pitched to magazines like Prevention and Better Homes and Garden on four self-defeating badges women wear–I’m Worried, I’m Stressed, I’m Busy, I’m a Martyr–with suggestions as to what the payoff is, what the price is and how to strip the badge. I’ve enlisted experts on all these topics. Better Homes and Gardens said it was too negative a slant, that they look for more pro-active stances. Haven’t heard from others. Wondering if you see another way to slant this so that it would be more saleable to the consumer market–or perhaps I’m targeting the wrong market?

    • Carol Tice

      You know, I think you’ve hit on another basic type of article that editors DO tend to pass on. They really like to limit the gloom and doom in consumer mags.

      Stay tuned for Wednesday’s post from Linda Formichelli right here, on how to turn those negative ideas into salable ones, Genita!

    • Katherine Swarts

      I got a somewhat similar piece of feedback on a self-branding slogan I tried (which I just realized is still on my Den Forum signature–now I’m trying to remember where to go to change it). It was “comfort to the stressed, depressed, and hard-pressed,” and my critic said it “reeked pure negativity” or something like that. I switched to “RICH writing–Radiant Inspiration for the Challenge to Happiness.”

      Are book publishers different from article publishers? I remember how such titles as Ten Stupid Things Women Do to Mess up Their Lives, A Child Called It, and who knows how many “the trouble with this whole world” books and angst-loaded novels have shot to the top of bestseller lists.

    • Katherine Swarts

      The topic per se doesn’t sound all that “un-consumery”–maybe the problem is in a query that is overly serious where it could be humorous, or spends 90% of the word count on the problem and mentions the solution almost as an afterthought. Or you might try a more behavioral-health-oriented market, such as Psychology Today. Just thoughts.

  3. Olatunji Femi

    undoubtedly, here seriously consist of island of resources that most newbie freelancer writer could absolutely benefit from like I’m doing now. 7 Types of Articles That Editors Hate and Don’t Want to Pay You For is really an eye opener as to how to operate better in the freelancing world.


  1. Part 2: How Freelance Copywriters Meet, Greet & Monetize in 6 Months - [...] read Carol Tice’s take on articles you WON’T be paid for. How many of these traps have you fallen…

Related Posts

You CAN Write a Query Letter That Gets a “Yes”: 5 Resources

Freelance writer getting a gig after learning to write a query letter.

Love them or hate them, queries are one of the most important marketing tools for any freelancer who wants to write for magazines. And the skills you learn from writing a good query letter also help business writers and copywriters pitch their potential clients.

If you’ve been sending queries off into space and never getting a reply, you may think it’s impossible to break into new magazines. But it’s not true! Editors are always looking for new talent.

To help you learn to write a query letter that will get you the gig, we’ve pulled together a collection of five of our best posts on pitching:

Can’t Write? Try These 9 Ideas for Writing Motivation

It’s the bane of every freelance writer’s life: You know you need to sit yourself down and get some writing done, but nothing happens. The writing motivation just isn’t there. Sometimes, you can't even make yourself sit down with the computer -- even if you...