How Kicking Craigslist Jump-Started My Freelance Writing Career

Carol Tice

Kicking Craigslist helped me find better freelance writing jobs - and jump-started my career. Makealivingwriting.comby Sarita Harbour

Are you desperately searching Craigslist trying to find freelance writing jobs?

I was. But not anymore.

Using techniques Carol Tice and Linda Formichelli teach in the Freelance Writers Den, not only did I kick my Craigslist habit, I gained four quality clients and two potential new projects in six weeks.

And they were all at better rates than I’d ever earned from Craigslist clients.

Why I Stopped Looking at the Free Job Boards

After several frustrating months wasting time searching online classifieds for better clients to replace the content mill work that was (barely) paying my bills, I took a two-day writing break to paint my kitchen.

I finally found time to listen to several Freelance Writers Den webinars.  As I taped, rolled, brushed and listened, a theme emerged.  Take a month to stop looking for quality freelance writing jobs on Craigslist and start marketing like crazy.

Here’s the thing.  For every legitimate small business using Craigslist to find freelance writers, there are hundreds of questionable characters who want 500 words for $10.

My Craigslist days were full of posts removed by authors within hours of appearing, ridiculously low rates, and requests for free work samples.

There were very few good freelance writing opportunities.

Even worse, it became a habit and a major time-suck. Up at six, coffee in hand, I’d go straight to Craigslist each morning.

Before I knew it, the kids were awake and my early morning work-time was gone with few, if any, leads to show for it.

How I Broke the Craigslist Habit in 5 Easy Steps

  • Remove the temptation.  I began by removing all bookmarks for job boards and online classified listings that were cluttering up my computer. It was scary, liberating, and made my toolbar and bookmark menu a lot neater.
  • Replace the activity.  Any addict will tell you that replacing unhealthy activities with healthy ones is key to staying on the path to recovery.  Replace Craigslist searching with identifying potential new clients and creating customized pitches.  I specialize in writing for online clients, and used Alexa rankings to identify top websites in my niches. Start at the lower ranked sites and work your way up the food chain.
  • Research.  My next step was to study current issues in my niches, and craft customized emails. These included an attention-grabbing subject line, a few possible titles, and detailed pitches for each target client. This took some time, but was worth it when my first marketing email resulted in two sold articles and an assignment for a third at a personal-finance website at almost triple the content mill rates.
  • Refine.  When the temptation to browse online classifieds for freelance writing jobs was overwhelming, I refined my search to better-quality job boards such as LinkedIn (job posters have to pay to list here), MediaBistro, and the Junk-Free Job Board on the Freelance Writer’s Den.  To date I have signed contracts with two clients found on the Junk-Free Board. One is an agency that pays $150 an article for finance topics that take roughly a couple hours to write.
  • Repeat. This isn’t a one-day thing.  I vowed to keep stick to my guns for at least a month, and I did.

Now, I’m working on replacing my $150 clients with ones that pay more. One new client I recently landed has multiple sites, lots of work, and pays $200 per 500-word post.

I learned that replacing Craigslist browsing with proactive, daily marketing leads to higher-paying jobs from better-quality clients.  It worked for me and it will work for you, too.

Sarita Harbour is a professional freelance writer specializing in web design, small business, personal finance and content marketing techniques. She is thrilled to have kicked her Craigslist habit.

Join my freelance writer community


  1. Kevin Lee

    It’s amazing how often I stumble upon an article from your website. This was a great post. Especially since I was contemplating on using CL for some leads to potential clients.

    Although I’m a few years late on reading this (some of the comment dates go back to 2012! Time really flies), I’m glad that I had a chance to read it so that I could avoid making a mistake in my career.

    Thanks again Carol.

    • Kevin Lee

      My apologies. I didn’t catch that it was written by Sarita. So thank you Sarita 🙂

  2. Unhip Chick

    Great post and just what I needed to read. I’ve been a freelance writer and communications consultant for a while now and am always looking for new clients. I’ve fallen into the same CL and job board rut that it seems everyone else has at some point in his/her freelance career. I’m going to switch things up now and use my membership in the Freelance Writer’s Den to learn how to better market myself. Thanks for the inspiration!

    • Carol Tice

      Cool — see you in there!

  3. Tommy

    the key to making CL work is two-fold: having the right software, and knowing how to avoid scams.

    There is software out there with which you can search all cities/countries and categories at once. This shaves hours off of a manual search. I won’t name names, but the software is out there and it’s affordable.

    You still have to prepare individual cover letters for each valuable lead, but this should be standard practice anyway. You can save more time still by knowing the red flags of CL spammers and scammers. You can find those on Google easily enough.

    Few CL posters will be willing to pay up front initially, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that they’re trying to scam you. There are a lot of big companies that use CL as just one of their channels for finding new talent.

    • Carol Tice

      Efficient software or no, Tommy, there’s still a bottom line that the vast majority of Craigslist ad posters aren’t offering a living wage. I got pretty efficient at scanning it over time, but when I analyzed my client base, my best clients never came from a CL ad.

      I don’t work for any business without an up-front deposit either — just too many writers I know who’ve told me about getting ripped off that way. So cruising Craigslist for leads is just not for me, at this point.

  4. Anne Galivan

    I have never used Craigslist, but did sign up for Elance a while ago. Forget that! I found the job postings there good for a laugh and that’s about it.

    Even though I haven’t used Craigslist, your ideas for finding higher paying gigs was helpful, especially since I am interested in writing for online sites as well. Thanks for the tips!

    • Sarita Harbour

      Hi Anne – I’m happy to hear you found some useful ideas. Hope they help you build your business and make more money from your writing.

Related Posts

You CAN Write a Query Letter That Gets a “Yes”: 5 Resources

Freelance writer getting a gig after learning to write a query letter.

Love them or hate them, queries are one of the most important marketing tools for any freelancer who wants to write for magazines. And the skills you learn from writing a good query letter also help business writers and copywriters pitch their potential clients.

If you’ve been sending queries off into space and never getting a reply, you may think it’s impossible to break into new magazines. But it’s not true! Editors are always looking for new talent.

To help you learn to write a query letter that will get you the gig, we’ve pulled together a collection of five of our best posts on pitching:

Can’t Write? Try These 9 Ideas for Writing Motivation

It’s the bane of every freelance writer’s life: You know you need to sit yourself down and get some writing done, but nothing happens. The writing motivation just isn’t there. Sometimes, you can't even make yourself sit down with the computer -- even if you...